Tag Archives: sean-duffy

The Day the Sky Closed

Let me see if I’ve got this straight. I have to go through a two-factor authentication process to order a slice of pizza online, but a routine upgrade of a router in Arkansas brought down the Federal Aviation Administration’s Network and shut down commercial flights nationwide. How does that happen?

Roughly 3,500 aircraft were airborne when the FAA halted departures nationwide on Friday because radar and communications data had become unreliable. The screen above, from the online service FlightAware, shows the traffic. Controllers and pilots relied on still-functioning equipment and established safety procedures to bring those planes down safely. But for about four hours, no planes were allowed to take off.

Although the ground stop was lifted Friday evening, the disruption continued throughout the weekend as airlines struggled to get aircraft and crews back into position. According to FlightAware, approximately 6,700 U.S. flights were canceled Saturday, followed by another 2,300 on Sunday. By early Monday, November 16, roughly 250 additional flights had been canceled and 620 delayed, although disruptions were significantly decreasing.

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said Saturday that a faulty router might have caused the communications outage. Replacing the router in Arkansas triggered abnormal network behavior with another recently upgraded router at a radar site in Amarillo, Texas. A broadcasting feature on the equipment began sending data far more broadly than intended, creating a data loop that flooded primary and backup routers nationwide

Duffy said the outage occurred during routine FAA telecommunications maintenance at a remote facility, where aging copper communications lines were being replaced with fiber-optic service. The work was being performed by L3Harris, the FAA’s longtime telecommunications contractor, as part of a broader modernization effort.

In my two-bedroom apartment I have three switches and one router. The last time I needed to make a change in my system was when my Scottish Terrier Mandy ate through cable supplying power to one of the switches. I wired around the failed switch until I got a new cable. Then I chose a time when neither my wife nor I had any pressing business to install it.

The FAA system is of course a little more complicated. The network can never be turned off entirely because there are always airplanes in the air. Nonetheless, it is gross negligence to install new equipment without monitoring it and being prepared to switch back to the pre-installation state if something goes wrong. I would also not do it at 4pm on a Friday which, if you’ve traveled you know, is a rush hour for the airlines. Saturday morning would be much better. It is the slowest time for the system.

A responsible government official would take responsibility, apologize to the public and the airlines, and order an investigation to determine exactly what went wrong and how to keep it from happening again. But “responsible government” is an oxymoron. Especially under the Trump administration.

Donald Trump has consistently staffed his government with people having only one attribute and it is not competence to do the job to which they have been appointed. The only requirement has been unqualified loyalty to Trump.

Duffy’s primary qualifications, cited during his January 2025 confirmation process. are his nine years in the House of Representatives, eight years as a county district attorney, and his bipartisan legislative work on regional infrastructure projects. Duffy lacked direct executive management experience leading a large agency, such as the DOT’s 55,000 employees, and had not served on congressional transportation committees. His career prior to his appointment included working as a lobbyist, a Fox Business co-host, and an early reality television role on MTV.

That first evening Duffy was joined by Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, who said investigators had found no evidence of a cyberattack. Reassuring words to be sure. But they came from a man whose qualifications to be chief security officer are that he left college at age 20 when his father fell ill to take over his family’s struggling plumbing company in Westville, Oklahoma and over the next 25 years expanded Mullin Plumbing into one of the largest regional service companies in the state. He too had served in the House. That’s all folks.

It took a few days to catch up to Trump himself. He immediately blamed Joe Biden for the network outage. I kid you not. An NBC reporter asked, if Donald Trump has been president for nearly six of the last ten years, and Republicans have controlled both chambers of Congress since January of last year, why hadn’t fixing the air traffic control system been a higher priority? Good questions.

In fact, billions to upgrade the FAA systems were included in Biden’s Infrastructure bill. Those are appropriations Trump immediately froze the day he took office. As many as 400 technical experts at the FAA were later fired by Elon Musk’s DOGE marauders, who were hell bent on getting rid of anyone who had technical expertise and were employed anywhere in the government.

For me the most alarming of the news to dribble out in the wake of this event it that some sixty or more routers recently installed had to have their configuration software modified. This implies that a bad set of instructions had been in use for some time, unchecked, unvetted, lurking around waiting to jump up and bite us all on the rear. That’s scary.

In the past week we have also encountered computer problems at Microsoft, at several major banks including Chase, Bank of America, US Bank, Wells Fargo, and Capital One, and at the National Security Agency.

I don’t know about you, but I am not ready to turn my life over to computerized artificial intelligence agents.

I’ll order my own pizza.

#####